Buc 'Em: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: RSL Soapbox for Real Salt Lake Fans!

Grading Out the Tampa Bay Buccaneers:  Offense

With it being a short week, we'll get all the "Grading out the Tampa Bay Buccaneers" columns into one extra super duper happy fun time 24 hour period.  When looking at each player/unit, we take into account what they did at their position.  If McCown delivers a strike to a WR but the WR tips it to a defensive player and it gets picked, I'm not holding that against McCown. 

As usual, we are looking at the previous game (Bucs @ Jags) and how each unit/individual did relative to their position on the team, expectations and other factors.  For example (fictitious):  Gaines Adams getting 2 hurries against first string opponent is worth more to me than him getting 2.5 sacks against the 4th string JV team. 

To check out the grades, click the jump and read on.

Star-divide

Offense

Quarterback

Byron Leftwich - Got the start against Jacksonville.  Didn't  have a great performance but was able to move the offense with moderate success.  Able to convert a 3rd a long with a strike delivered in the middle of the field.  Still shows long windup, but with good protection was able to find receivers.  Displayed little touch on his passes, relying on arm strength.  When he has time, is able to survey the field.  Not as strong as Week 1, but not a huge step back.  Grade:  B-

Luke McCown - Huge turnaround from week 1.  Looked decisive, didn't escape pocket unnecessarily, was able to connect with two good throws for touchdowns.  Worked with a short field, but was able to convert.  Made good reads on most passes. Showed ability to make tough throws in tight spaces.  Protected the ball.  Grade: A-

Josh Freeman -  Showed same habit of staring down receivers.  Relied too much on arm strength with no touch shown.  Continued to miss high on passes.  Did complete some good passes.  Accuracy was worse than last week, but typically missed in right places.  Able to move pretty well for a bigger quarterback, as shown on his TD run.  Needs work on his celebrations. Grade: C+ without celebration, C- when factoring in celebration

Josh Johnson - After the media hype, underperformed.  Opportunities were limited.  Did move well out of pocket, but no game changing plays. Ability still remains a threat.  Showed good accuracy in limited chances.  Still needs some game time.  Grade:  C-

Running Backs

Derrick Ward - Looked much better in week 2.  Broke a few long runs showing good power, speed, vision, and agility.  Next career may be Olympic hurdler.  Was able to make guys miss 1 on 1.  Got to second level quickly and efficiently and continually fell forward.  Took advantage of holes provided by OL.  Good fit in the system.  Grade: B

Kareem Huggins -  Displayed good quickness, good tenacity, and an ability to make a guy miss.  Shook a few tacklers with some nasty jukes.  Shifty runner who would be labeled third down back.  Need to see blocking ability before crowning him with that title.  Not too powerful, was often stopped at point of first solid contact.  Grade: C+

B.J. Askew - Will prove to be a HUGE asset in the running game.  Can carry out of the FB position and be a good option.  Has good hands and remains a threat to block, run or catch the ball.  Grade: B+

Wide Receivers

Michael Clayton - Was able to get most fans to shut up about the drops, for a week.  Showed good awareness in routes.  Able to catch tough passes.  Still a brutal blocker that will help the running game.  If he can continue on this road, will be a good player in this offense. Showed ability to scoop tough throws.  Still need to see him catch on run, as that has been his bugaboo. Grade: B-

Bryan Clark - Appears as if he doesn't want the 3rd WR spot.  Dropped an easy pass that hit him in hands.  Doesn't seem to separate well in routes.  Not going to demand attention.  Grade: C

Sammy Stroughter - Either our 3rd WR now or in the near future.  Showed ability to take a hit, hang on to ball and run good route all on same play.  Has speed to get open, and appears to have sure hands.  Asset in other phases of game.  (Editor's Note:  Sammy Stroughter will be the end of Dexter Jackson.  They play the same positions, WR/KR/PR, Sammy already has better hands, willingness to take a hit, vision, and security.  With the emergence of SS, D-Jack may be on the unemployment line.  Similar skill set, but fear of contact won't help him make the team, along with injuries.) Grade: B+

Jerramy Stevens - All personal issues aside, will continue to be a weapon for any quarterback.  Nice route, good hands, and good finish will do nothing to deter from his fans. Size advantage is big plus in red zone.  Grade: B

Kellen Winslow - It may just be me, but is this guy doing anything?  He's played both weeks and done little to nothing.  I'd like to see him utilized more.  Don't know if he isn't showing up due to limited snaps, injuries, or lack of familiarity, but trading away a pick and spending some cash, I want more from him.  Grade: D

The Others - Urrutia, Stovall and other remain largely unimpressive.  They can contribute on team, but aren't making strides or showing well on the field. With Clayton still banged up, would be nice to see them with another QB  Grade: C-

Offensive Line

First String - Definite progress. Showed ability to open holes for running game.  Davin Joseph and Jeremy Zuttah were destroying opposing DT's in run game.  Pass protection was much better with defined pocket and above average time for QB's.  A few penalties but a much needed huge step forward.  Grade: B

Every other string - About what you'd expect from the other guys.  Some nice plays, overshadowed by breakdowns and penalties.  Some good provide some good depth on line, but won't make a mark anywhere else.  Grade: C

After a pretty blah performance last week, the offense rebounded this week with more consistency, more big plays, and a better discipline in moving the ball.  Offensive line provided time and holes when needed, quarterbacks delivered, running backs leapt over tall buildings, and receivers (generally) made plays.  Progress is important, and we saw plenty on Saturday night.  Grade: B-

0 recs  |  Comment 5 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Josh Johnson deserves an incomplete

Lack of opportunity, commitment to running the ball

Follow Me on Twitter @FreeZorilla

by FreeZorilla on Aug 25, 2009 2:20 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

2/4 21 yards and a fumble

1 run for 3 yards. 2 of his throws weren’t on target. I think it’s slightly worse than average for him, given the competition. For him to hang on, he has to wow. He does need more time on the field (hoping he sees most of the non McCown/Leftwich time on Thurs), but the reality is he has about 2-3 quarters of football left to prove his worth, and it will be playing with and against second/third/fourth stringers

www.bucem.com - SBNation's source for all things Buccaneer

by Buc Wild on Aug 25, 2009 2:27 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

The fumble was not lost just as an FYI

www.bucem.com - SBNation's source for all things Buccaneer

by Buc Wild on Aug 25, 2009 2:27 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Josh Johnson will be starting for Jon Gruden somewhere in three years...

He picked him because he is very accurate and takes care of the ball, at least he has a history of that at the collegiate level. Thats my risky pick at least.
Despite whos getting the nod Thursday, I think Luke McCown wins the job.

I wouldnt worry about K2. Come regular season, you will see him often enough!

My Buddy went somewhere to get high and watch some good fights, and after a few minutes a Bucs Practice broke out.

by Niko Houllis on Aug 25, 2009 4:21 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Good Evaluation

I just want to start by sayinig that the JAGS ARE AWEFUL!!!! They applied no pressure defensively and all of our QB’s looked good against them. They will be lucky to win 4 games this year with that defense and lack of running game. WR had game of his life, doubt he will do it again.

Leftwich looked good to me, he overthrew 2 big opportunities but atleast he saw them. The boom to stovall and the overthrow to Clayton. I was encouraged by watching the offense run the ball and throw the ball the way they did. They need to clean up the penalties and the negative plays but it was good to see Leftwich complete that 3 and 16.

Luke looked better but lets not get carried away, he had short fields on both of them and the one he didn’t move the ball he went 3 and out. I have yet to see luke move the ball when he has more than half of the field to go. Not encouraging to me. He did make the most of his opportunities which was good but i think that BL , Freeman and JJ would have converted a TD on both drives -def on the 20 yard drive after the straugther return.

Freeman is improving and that is good, he will not be in the QB race so i will just say I like what I saw. He was a little high on his throws but he will have time to improve .

JJ – Time is running out

Sammie straughter is my Hero!!! The guy can do it all and I will be upset if he isn’t atleast the 4th receiver. He runs great routes and has big play cabability, something you can’t teach. He just gets into the open field and he makes plays.

Brian Clark – He should be the 5th receiver solely because of his special teams and hustle. He has dropped numerous passes and just seems to be unable to separate from defenders.

Stovall – I am really routing for him. He looked alot better this game but I would like to see him turn in a good performance vs the Dolphins. He is big, nice speed and has OK hands. I would like to see him catch the balls that are thrown to him at a higher rate. he is around 50 percent on his catches. But I like his potential.

Hankton – PLEASE CUT HIM A.S.A.P. !!!! The guy can’t catch a cold in alaska with no clothes on.

OL – looked dominating, opened holes and pass blocked. Will have a nice test vs the dolphins.

Winslow is getting paid all of that money and doesn’t feel that he needs to work hard yet but I believe he is a gamer. He will show up on sundays, he just doesn’t seem to excited about this whole preseason thing.

Stevens looked good as well as all of the running backs.

by tbbuc4 on Aug 25, 2009 5:54 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Buc 'Em, SBNation's home of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Your one stop for Buccaneers info, videos, opinions and more.
Start posting about the Buccaneers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Percy-harvin-p1_small
Does Josh Freeman have poise?
Wood-83_small
Time For A What If? Moment
Ou_logo_youtube_blue_55_55_small
THATS A WIN VS THE FINS...CUZ WE HAVE NOTHING TO LOSE!
Tampa_bay_buccaneers_primary_logo_small
Official discussion board for Week 10 officiating
Stairs_small
Quarterback Cliche's I Hate
Nfl_tampa_bay_buccaneers_1_small
Several Bucs listed on early injury report for Week 10
Percy-harvin-p1_small
Bucs vs Dolphins (Florida bragging rights)
Tampa_bay_buccaneers_primary_logo_small
Josh Bidwell, a police officer, four Washington Apples and Doug Williams
Small
DO YOU BELIEVE IN MAGIC? THE BUCS JUST MIGHT!
Small
Congratulations!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Acme Packing Company
Matthews: NFL Rookie of the Week
Gang Green Nation
Another Patriot Running his Mouth (surprise)-- Moss on Revis
Gang Green Nation
How to Beat the Cheats-- Sunday Preview

Twitter Feed


Editor & Lead Writers

1001_large_small Niko Houllis

Nfl_tampa_bay_buccaneers_1_small Buc Wild

Tampa_bay_buccaneers_primary_logo_small Paul Mueller

Assistant Writers

Bucco_bruce_small Craig T

Stairs_small UNFNOLE

Buclogo_small LeeCaz

218px-tampa_bay_buccaneers_logo bucsfandave